A delegation
of five parliamentarians representing the Canadian Section of ParlAmericas
travelled to Guatemala City, Guatemala from 19 to 23 January 2013, and then on
to San Salvador, El Salvador from 23 to 26 January 2013. The delegation was led
by Mr. Earl Dreeshen, M.P.; also participating were the Honourable Jim Munson,
Senator, Mr. François Pilon, M.P, Mr. Scott Simms, M.P., and Mr. Bernard
Trottier, M.P. The parliamentarians were assisted by Ms. Guyanne Desforges,
Association Secretary to the Canadian Section, and Mr. Andre Barnes, the
association analyst from the Library of Parliament.
The purpose
of this bilateral visit was to strengthen the parliamentary ties between
Canada, and Guatemala and El Salvador; promote ParlAmericas as a liaison
between the Parliaments of the Americas; and further hemispheric dialogue
concerning issues of mutual importance, such as trade and investment
opportunities, human rights, and social and economic conditions.
Guatemala,
Central America’s largest country and the region’s largest economy, is an
important partner for Canada and is the key country of focus for Canada’s
engagement on Central American security. Canada maintains strong diplomatic
ties and growing trade relations with Guatemala and is actively engaged in the
country on a wide range of issues, including human rights protection, trade and
investment, corporate responsibility, and efforts to improve the delivery of
security and justice in the country. In recent years, deepening ties have been
underscored by high-level contact, including visits to Guatemala by the
Governor General in 2009 and 2012, and four visits by the Minister of State
Foreign Affairs (Americas) since 2009.
El Salvador
is also an important partner for Canada in Central America and a key country in
Canada’s engagement in the Americas. 2011 marked the 50th
anniversary of diplomatic relations between Canada and El Salvador. The two
countries have enjoyed growing trade relations, with two-way merchandise
totalling $165.6 million in 2011 (a 34.3% increase from 2010). In 2010, Canada
concluded an open skies-type air transport agreement with El Salvador and is
currently working with El Salvador to ensure that this agreement is signed and
ratified as quickly as possible. ParlAmericas performs an important role in the
hemisphere, seeking to encourage the sharing of experiences and best practices
amongst its members. It works to strengthen the role of legislatures in
democratic development; promote harmonization of legislation; and increase
hemispheric integration and sustainable, harmonious development in the region.
This bilateral visit provided the Canadian delegation with an invaluable
opportunity to cultivate positive inter-parliamentary relations between
Canadian, and Guatemalan and El Salvadorian parliamentarians. It also allowed
the Canadian delegation to engage in frank and focussed discussions with
decision-makers in the region, to gain a clearer picture of the status of
Canadian interests, to advance Canadian interests and values, and to acquire a
more complete comprehension of the issues and challenges faced by citizens in
Guatemala and El Salvador.
BILATERAL
VISIT TO GUATEMALA
A. Meeting with the Canadian Ambassador to Guatemala
On 21
January 2013, the Canadian delegation met with Mr. Hugues R. Rousseau,
Ambassador of Canada to Guatemala, his political program manager, as well as
the Embassy’s security manager, at the Canadian Embassy in Guatemala City.
Delegates were provided with a substantive briefing on Canadian-Guatemalan
relations, as well as an overview of the issues of importance in Guatemala.
It was noted
that Canada and Guatemala celebrated 50 years of formal diplomatic relations in
2011. The Embassy’s role is to strengthen these relations. The Embassy issues
over 5,000 work permits each year, which allowed temporary workers to enter
Canada. Guatemala’s role as an important regional partner has been highlighted
by a series of recent visits by the Hon. Diane Ablonczy, Minister of State of
Foreign Affairs and the planned visit of Major-General R.D. Foster.
Two-way
trade between Canada and Guatemala totalled $512 million in 2012 ($110 million
in exports from Canada). Canada’s interest in securing a free trade agreement
with Guatemala to further bolster trade between the two countries was noted.
Direct Canadian investment in Guatemala totalled approximately $1 billion in
2012. The delegation was provided with information concerning Goldcorp Inc.’s
Marlin Mine, a large, well-established mining project in Guatemala.
It was noted
that Guatemala was the recipient of approximately $5 million per year from the
Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) for programs which focus
primarily on food security and justice issues. Canadian federal funds amounting
to $9.8 million since 2009 have also been provided through the Stabilization
and Reconstruction Task Force (START) in order to strengthen justice
institutions, and contribute to transitional justice. The Canadian government
is also looking at ways to expand defence relations and training co-operation
with Guatemala on security issues. The Anti-Crime Capacity Building Program
(ACCBP) also funds initiatives in the security sector reform; the International
Commission Against Impunity (CICIG), an international commission working to
build the capacity of state institutions to deal with cases of impunity, which
has received $11.5 million over six years through CIDA; and food security and
rural development programs, which have received $22 million to date from CIDA.
The
Guatemalan economy remains the largest in Central America. It features,
however, high levels of poverty, corruption, and income inequality, coupled
with a large informal economy, the lowest tax collection rate in the Americas,
and an inadequate social safety net. It was noted that remittances play an
important role in the economy, accounting for between $4 and 5 billion
annually.
Violence and
armed conflict are also major issues in Guatemala. Guatemala is part of the
main drug route to North America, and organized crime and its concomitant
violence run rampant. In addition to narcotics, Guatemala faces problems with
the smuggling of arms and humans, along with money laundering, kidnapping,
gangs and extortion. Another source of civil unrest relates to the social
conflict concerning workers and land rights. The rates of domestic violence
against women and children are also high.
It was noted
also that certain social issues confront Guatemala, including lack of proper
education, which has led to high illiteracy rates, and which stems, in part,
from inadequate training for teachers. Malnutrition rates in Guatemala are the
highest in the region, and are among the top three or four in the world. It was
noted that nutritional deficiencies affect cognitive development.
Lastly, it
was noted that Guatemala’s President Otto Perez Molina has indicated that the
focus of his administration would be on economic matters (i.e. tax collection),
security (i.e. bolstering the justice system) and social issues (i.e. improving
education standards, and lowering malnutrition rates).
B. Meeting with the Canada–Guatemala Chamber of Commerce
On 21
January 2013, the delegation met with members of the Canada–Guatemala Chamber
of Commerce at the Canadian Embassy in Guatemala City.
Founded five
years ago, the membership of the Chamber of Commerce has expanded from 9 to 50
in the past two years. The purpose of the Chamber of Commerce is to promote
profitable and productive relations between Canada and Guatemala, and to act as
a partner in the development of bilateral trade activity between the two
countries. The membership of the Chamber of Commerce is diverse, and included,
for example, mining operations, suppliers, and hydro-electric companies.
Members noted that, at present, a trade imbalance described as lopsided exists
between Guatemala and Canada, with Guatemalan exports to Canada far exceeding
imports. He also noted that, in general, the trade relations between the two
countries are on the right track and growing
A possible
free trade agreement between Canada and Guatemala arose as a topic of interest
among the delegates and the members of the Chamber of Commerce. It was noted by
members of the Chamber of Commerce that a free trade agreement remains a high
priority for them, as it would provide security to investments by Canadians.
Members noted that open market access would greatly assist Canadian businesses,
in particular Canada’s beef and pork producers, who at present incur a 15%
additional tax when entering the Guatemalan market. Other options were raised
such as a foreign investment protection agreement to provide greater security
to Canadian investments, or a tax information exchange to facilitate the moving
of investment capital between the two countries.
Questions
arose from delegates as to the mining situation in Guatemala. Representatives
from the mining industry explained their operations, including details on
investments that have been made in day-to-day infrastructure and services in
the communities in which their mines are located, as well as information on
certain long term programs that have been put in place for such communities. An
example was given of a mining firm that had funded a silversmith program in
which citizens residing near a mine received training in silversmithing. Upon
the future closure of the mine, the area could become a tourist destination for
its silver. It was also noted that mining operations in Guatemala have been
working with agricultural associations to improve the agricultural techniques
and yields of local farmers.
The Canadian
delegates also raised questions concerning the hydroelectricity industry in
Guatemala. It was indicated by members of the Chamber of Commerce that
potential abounded in Guatemala for low impact, small- to medium-sized
hydroelectric operations throughout the country. Such projects, in their view,
did not require subsidies, and could tap into a demand for megawatts which
continues to grow each year. Generally, energy in the country is expensive as
it is produced predominantly by oil.
The issue of
personal security in Guatemala arose, and members of the Chamber of Commerce
indicated that it remains significant. The overall lack of personal security in
the country acts to dissuade qualified candidates, especially those residing
outside the country, making recruitment for vacant posts within their
businesses challenging. Members noted that many opportunities exist for long
term investments by Canadian companies in Guatemala. While much progress still
needs to be made in education and human capital, the climate for investment
continues to improve. The meeting concluded with Mr. Dreeshen thanking the
members of the Chamber of Commerce for their viewpoints.
C. Working Lunch with Guatemalan Congresspersons
On 21
January 2013, the delegation met with Congresspersons from the Congress of the
Republic of Guatemala for a working lunch at the Hotel Panamerican in Guatemala
City. In attendance at this meeting was Mr. Christian Boussinot, Second-Vice
President of Congress; Mr. Felipe Alejos, President of Migrants Commission, and
Mr. Manuel Villacorta, President of the Foreign Affairs Commission.
Mr.
Boussinot began the working lunch by welcoming the Canadian delegation on
behalf of President of Congress. He indicated that such meetings were great
opportunities to exchange ideas and for finding ways for mutual co-operation.
Mr. Alejos, too, greeted the delegation and indicated his interest in hearing
about the Canadian parliamentary system. Mr. Dreeshen noted how thankful the
delegation was for the opportunity to meet with the Congresspersons and
expressed the delegation’s interest in having an open discussion on topics of
mutual interest.
The topic of
public service turnover following each change of government arose. The
Congresspersons indicated that the present system was put in place following
the peace accords in 1996. The law at present is such that, following each
change of government (at four year intervals), the majority of upper-level
positions in the public service are vacated and replacements brought in. In
effect, Mr. Boussinot noted that Guatemala is a new democracy, and a precedent
has been set of utilizing high-level public service positions for patronage
appointments in order to service political debts. He noted, though, that a bill
is presently before Congress which seeks to guarantee better security and
continuity of public service positions.
The
education system was also discussed. The Congresspersons stated that changes
are needed, especially in terms of training for teachers. The challenge which
exists in Guatemala, as a poor country, is that the average Guatemalan is more
concerned with finding work to satisfy basic needs than in continuing on with
higher levels of education.
The human
rights situation in Guatemala was also addressed. The Congresspersons indicated
that the situation was improving. They noted that the country emerged from a
civil confrontation in 1996 which had lasted over thirty years, during which
time the human rights situation had deteriorated to practical non-existence. At
present, state institutions are fostering greater participation from civil
society, and the country is moving towards greater openness and transparency on
the part of its institutions. It was noted, though, that this is an on-going
process and that it will take time to build public confidence.
The
inclusion of indigenous groups in the decision-making process was raised. The
Congresspersons indicated that 18 of 158 Congresspersons are of indigenous
descent. It was noted that the Congress has been working to promote equal
social participation across ethnicities and to also promote the participation
of women in political life.
Mr.
Villacorta commented that, in his view, the temporary worker program with
Canada has been a great success and he wanted to express his appreciation to
the delegation. Mr. Dreeshen concluded the meeting by thanking the
Congresspersons for their time and viewpoints.
D. Meeting with NGOS (Citizen Security)
In the
afternoon of 21 January 2013, the Canadian delegation met with individuals
representing non-governmental organizations (NGOs) that, in conjunction with
state institutions, work to strengthen citizen security in Guatemala. The
meeting took place at the Canadian Embassy in Guatemala City. The meeting began
with Mr. Dreeshen offering welcoming remarks and thanking the participants for
the opportunity to learn about their organizations and the work they do to
assist Guatemalans.
The
opportunities offered to youth in Guatemala arose as a topic of discussion. It
was noted that limited support from the state exists, in terms of education and
other youth programs. Participants stated that it is easier for a youth to get
a hold of an AK-47 than a high school degree. It was noted that the drop-out
rate in high school is approximately 80%. In these circumstances, many youths
view their best options to be either migration or to get involved with a gang
in order to earn an income. It was further noted that remittances are the
highest form of income for Guatemalan families, and that this, by definition,
also causes disintegration of the family unit, creating a void in terms of parental
guidance which leaves youths susceptible to gang participation. In addition,
there is a lack of state programs to keep at risk youths occupied during
non-school hours, again contributing to gang participation. A final issue
mentioned was that youth feel a lack of sense of citizenry.
The mining
industry in Guatemala was also discussed. It was noted that the country
continues to operate under a lax and outdated mining law, whose original
purpose was to attract foreign investment, and as such is disproportionately
advantageous to mining companies. The Minister of the Economy is reportedly,
however, working to bring improvements to Guatemala’s mining law. The low
public opinion approval for mining in Guatemala was also discussed. It was
noted that mining companies need to communicate the benefits of mining more
effectively, by, for instance, engaging in a consultation and communication
phase with local communities prior to opening their facilities. Also of
importance was the need for local communities to retain a portion of the
profits generated by mining companies. In this respect, it was indicated that
NGOs who oppose any and all development should not be confused with a
community’s right to oppose economic proposals. It was again also noted that in
rural areas, mining companies are expected to take on the role ordinarily
served by the state.
Other topics
of discussion included the need for Guatemala to create a national development
plan. Also mentioned were the benefits of Canadian federal funds aimed at
providing access to credit for small- and medium-sized entrepreneurs and women
entrepreneurs. The latter were especially noteworthy as women earning an income
can shift the balance of power in households.
E. Dinner at the Official Residence of the Canadian Ambassador
In the
evening of 21 January 2013, the delegation was received for a dinner at the
official residence of the Canadian Ambassador to Guatemala, in Guatemala City.
Prior to the commencement of the meal, one guest offered comments to the Canadian
delegation concerning human rights issues in Guatemala, especially in respect
of indigenous peoples. The work of the Transparency Commission was discussed,
including its role in developing state policy to combat corruption; increasing
the public’s access to state information and operations in order to allow for
social audit; increasing transparency of decision-making in order to reduce
arbitrariness; modernizing the state through “e-government” initiatives; and
developing legislation in policy areas such as mining, construction, stolen
assets, health, and transportation. Both Ambassador Rousseau and Mr. Dreeshen
thanked the discussants for their valuable interchange, and indicated that such
issues were of great interest to the delegation.
F. Meeting with like-minded foreign embassy Officials
The morning
of 22 January 2013, the delegation met with officials with like-minded foreign
embassy officials to discuss the security situation in the region.
The
delegation was provided with an overview of narcotic trafficking in the region.
It was noted that Guatemala is located in a strategic position along the
corridor which runs from Columbia to the U.S., with 90% of U.S.-bound narcotics
passing through Guatemala
The
delegation was apprised of the recent successful extradition of Guatemalan drug
trafficker Walther Overdick to the U.S., the first such deportation in
approximately a decade. It is hoped that the threat of deportation will
increase co-operation on the part of Guatemalans charged with drug trafficking
and facing extradition.
It was noted
that the number one issue among Guatemalans is citizen security. Building the
capacity of police is an important task, one in which Canada is assisting. In
terms of bright spots in respect of the efforts to combat drug trafficking
Guatemala, it was noted that the President and the Attorney General have
indicated that it is their priority to establish a unified and safe Guatemalan
society, and are taking steps to achieve this goal
G. Working Lunch with NGOs
On 22 January
2013, the Canadian delegation held a working lunch with individuals
representing NGOs who work to strengthen transparency and accountability in
Guatemala. Mr. Dreeshen began the meeting by thanking the participants for
attending, and indicating that the delegation looked forward to learning about
the issues of importance in their policy fields.
The
delegation was provided with a briefing on the weak state of Guatemala’s
democracy. It was noted that taxation is a chronic problem, with only 10.8% of
GDP derived from tax collection. In terms of social problems, approximately 50%
of children under five years of age suffer from malnutrition. Participants
noted that wealth inequality in Guatemala is the highest in the region, and
that the rich do not pay adequate taxes and do not feel compelled to because
the government is so corrupt. Other issues touched on included the fact that
individuals tend only to run for political office out of self-interest and
personal gain; and that the old business elite employs an exploitation model to
create their wealth, including low wages and poor living conditions, for the
most part exploiting the country’s large indigenous population. Participants
noted that high levels of corruption exist across all Central American countries.
In Guatemala, corruption has infiltrated the police, the justice system,
political parties, and state and municipal governments.
A discussion
arose concerning the mining industry in Guatemala. Participants noted that
mining is a legitimate and necessary economic activity. They indicated,
however, that in Guatemala, the mining industry lacks transparency in their
operations, is insufficiently regulated, the royalties they pay are too low
compared to other countries, and that the tax rate imposed by law is
negligible. Indeed, they noted that the tax and royalty rates are so low that
mining companies voluntary pay income taxes and royalties as a gesture of
goodwill. It was also noted that the new mining law before Congress has
stalled. The poor public perception of mining in Guatemala was discussed, and
it was noted that the faulty mining legislation with its insignificant tax and
royalty obligations, is at least in part to blame for this poor perception.
Participants acknowledged that a free trade agreement with Canada would improve
benchmarks and standards, but also indicated that stability and rule of law in
the country needed to be improved.
Participants
indicated that improvements to state transparency have, in the recent past,
stalled or even regressed. Each four years, he noted, a new government is
elected and disassembles the work of the previous administration, including
even positive advancements in access to information. He also acknowledged that
the lack of a stable professional public service is very problematic.
H. Meeting with NGO
In the
afternoon of 22 January 2013, the delegation met with an NGO working on
corporate social responsibility issues. Participants provided the delegation
with the overview of role and vision of their organization, which promotes
corporate social responsibility (CSR) among businesses in the Central American
region, instils a culture of compliance within these businesses to the rule of
law, and assists in implementing best industry practices. It has also developed
CSR benchmarks for self-assessment for local businesses relevant to the
realities in Central America.
One
initiative the organization is working on is an attempt to establish a map of
positive and negative business leaders throughout the country, in order to
track who is making money and having success, and which models to emulate or
avoid. It was noted that the Guatemalan economy needs its younger generations
to take an active interest in the betterment of their country, to bring new
perspectives to old institutions and stimulate positive change. . As such, in
the long term, the strengthening of institutions and anti-corruption policies
are priorities. Mr. Dreeshen concluded the meeting by thanking the
participants, on behalf of the delegation, for their frank and open views on
the state of affairs in Guatemala.
BILATERAL
VISIT TO EL SALVADOR
A. Meeting with the President of El Salvador’s Assembly
In the
evening of 23 January 2012, the delegation attended a working dinner hosted by
the Canadian Ambassador to El Salvador, Mr Pierre Giroux at the Ciao Bella
restaurant in San Salvador, El Salvador. The guest of Honour was Mr. Sigfrido
Reyes, the President of the Legislative Assembly of El Salvador, Also in
attendance at the dinner were; Ms. Blanca Noemi Coto Estrada, Member of the
Legislative Assembly (MLA); Ms. Margarita Escobar, MLA; Mr. Guillermo Gallegos,
MLA; Ms. Silvia Estela Ostorga, MLA; Ms. Mariella Pena Pinto, MLA; and Mr.
Mario Antonio Ponce Lopez, MLA. The dinner provided Mr. Reyes with an
opportunity to greet the delegation and allowed for informal discussions
concerning topics of interest among the parliamentarians.
On the
morning of 24 January 2013, the delegation, along with Ambassador Giroux, met
with Mr. Reyes at the Legislative Assembly in San Salvador, El Salvador. In his
opening remarks, Mr. Reyes offered his welcome to the Assembly, an institution
which was created after El Salvador achieved independence in 1821. Mr. Dreeshen
thanked Mr. Reyes for taking the time to meet with the delegation and indicated
the delegation’s interest in learning more about their system of government,
society and priorities.
Mr. Reyes
provided the delegation with an overview of the El Salvador’s political system.
He noted that there were 84 members in the Assembly from 6 political parties.
The issues of interest and focus in the legislature included climate change and
the status of women (approximately 25% of the membership of the Assembly was
female). Mr. Reyes added that two women had served in his role as President of
the Assembly.
Mr. Reyes
noted that El Salvador emerged in 1992 from 12 years of civil war that left
70,000 civilians dead. The Peace Accords of 1992 ushered in a new era of
democratic reform, strengthening of human rights and state institutions,
modernization of the electoral system, and an increase in pluralism. He
highlighted the introduction of the right to vote for El Salvadorians living
abroad (close to 150,000 to 160,000 in Canada and the U.S.; for every two El
Salvadorians living in El Salvador, one El Salvadorian lives abroad). He also
set out the challenges faced by El Salvador, including low levels of
investment, high unemployment, poverty, a lack of housing, a lack of access to
health services and education, and violence and insecurity brought on, in part,
by the drug cartels.
A discussion
ensued with the delegation in which women’s rights issues in El Salvador was
raised. The President of the Assembly indicated this is an issue of importance
to the Assembly and steps are being taken to modernize people’s mentality. A
question arose as to the risks posed by allowing citizens to vote from abroad.
Mr. Reyes indicated that the participation from citizens living abroad was low
but that also, through their remittances, El Salvadorians living abroad
contribute vitally to the domestic economy. Direct foreign investment was also
raised as a point of discussion. The President indicated that a bill is before
Congress to reduce barriers and provide incentives to investors, as well as to
strengthen legal and physical security of their investments. Another bill is
also before Congress that would provide for partnerships between domestic and
foreign companies in strategic sectors of the economy. Mr. Reyes also raised
with the delegation the issue of a Salvadoran citizen living in British
Columbia threatened with deportation; Mr. Reyes’ desire to see the temporary
worker program expanded; and his desire to see access to visas to Canada made
more accessible. He concluded by emphasizing the potential of his country,
including its climate, bountiful resources, and skilled labour pool. Mr.
Dreeshen thanked Mr. Reyes, on behalf of the delegation, for taking the time to
meet with the delegation and for sharing his ideas on how to strengthen the
relationship between Canada and El Salvador.
B. Meeting with Academics and Experts
On 24
January 2013, the delegation met with academics, and security and democracy
experts to discuss the state of democratic institutions; armed violence; and
violence against women, children and youth. An academic began the roundtable
by providing the delegates with an overview of the state of the El Salvadorian
democracy. He indicated that the country has undergone a series of
transformations to modernize its political system. He listed four major
accomplishments in this regard:
1.They
have established the principle that legitimate political action is the only
means to access state power;
2.They
have established who are the legitimate political actors (i.e. political
parties);
3.They
have established the legitimacy of the process of transition from one
government to its successor without upheaval or overthrow; and
4.They
have built institutions which provide for less uncertainty and arbitrariness in
decision-making.
However,
four challenges remain:
1.Bipartisan polarization;
2.The need for institutionalized space for
dialogue;
3.The need to launch a new generation of political
reforms (e.g. social auditing, fiscal responsibility, etc.); and
4.The need to establish a new socio-economic pact
with the country.
A Human
Rights expert provided the delegation with a summary of human rights issues in
El Salvador. At present, she indicated that greater space exists in El Salvador
for meaningful discussions about the state, whereas previously citizens would
have feared persecution. The country has experienced an increase in diversity
of views, and a greater overall democratization. The armed forces have been
recognised as having a specific constitutional role, which acts as a brake on
its historical propensity to vie for power. El Salvador has also created a new,
professional civil police. Yet the country still faces a complex social
violence situation, caused in large part by organized crime. She noted that the
number of firearms in the country has reached the same levels today as during
the civil war. She stated that greater social investment is needed to assist
youth at risk. Investment is also needed to advance the fight against impunity,
and strengthen institutions in order to rid them of the infiltration by
organized crime.
A short
discussion ensued in which the speakers provided additional information on the
following topics: youth at risk and violence against women (the country direly
needs better social policies and programs directed at those vulnerable groups);
rights of gays and lesbians (cultural barriers continue to exist for awareness,
tolerance and recognition); rights of the elderly (there exist a complete lack
of social policies and programs; the elderly receive no benefits from the
state); and the growth of the industry of security in El Salvador (violence and
security measures against such violence have grown into an important business).
A security
academic then provided the delegation with a briefing concerning firearm
violence in El Salvador and Central America. He stated that there were
approximately 2.5 to 3 million firearms in Central America, of which two out of
three are illegal (i.e. not registered). He also stated that 85% of the victims
of firearm-related violence are youth aged 14 to 20 years. A recent Sistema de
la Integración Centroamericana (SICA) study found that it was easier for a
youth in El Salvador to get a firearm than to get a job. He also noted that
firearm possession has a gender bias in that it is men who tend to possess
firearms and also commit violent acts. Part of the issue concerns weak border
controls allowing firearms to be smuggled into the country along the same
corridor as drugs and humans. In terms of ammunition being legally imported
into the region, he indicated that the levels equal those of a time of war. The
debate remains on-going in El Salvador about disarmament and how to do so.
A governance
expert briefed the delegation about the climate of violence which exists in El
Salvador. She noted that it has been one of the most violent countries in the
world over the past decade, especially in respect of youth violence. There are
high rates of robbery, extortion, and “disappearances” (i.e. citizens who
simply went missing). Violence in El Salvador disproportionately affects women
and children. She also discussed the recent cease-fire declared between gangs
in El Salvador, after which there occurred a decrease in homicides by about
60%. Improving the situation is an on-going challenge; institutions need to be
allocated resources in order to respond in a co-ordinated and concerted way in
terms of prevention of violence.
An expert on
youth issues briefed the delegation concerning at-risk youth in El Salvador. He
noted that 40% of the population of the country is aged 0 to 15 years, and that
50% of the poor in the country are children, while 50% of children are poor.
Poor children tend to have higher mortality rates, attend less school and
suffer from malnutrition. In respect of family, 913,000 children live in
households without either a mother or a father; 400,000 children are part of a
family in which a mother or father has migrated abroad; 7 out 10 children report
being victims of physical or emotional violence; and 73% of girls aged 0 to 18
have experienced gender-based, sexual violence. In terms of deaths, UNICEF
estimated that approximately six youths (aged 0 to 18) were killed per week in
2011. He provided the delegation with UNICEF’s recommendations on this issue,
which included: providing space for children in school and developing programs
to keep them there; strengthening community-based prevention and detection of
violence against children; and emphasizing early childhood development as a
violence prevention strategy. He noted that there are laws in place already to
protect children but far too little will and resources to see them properly
applied.
A gender
issues expert provided the delegation with information concerning the status of
women in El Salvador. She indicated that the country has the highest levels of
domestic violence in Central America. Generally, there exists a troubling
cultural tolerance associated with violence against women and femicide. Indeed,
there is very little awareness about the issue. Women are not included in
decision-making processes in the household and are generally viewed as being
responsible for traditional roles such as domestic caretakers. She noted that
progress had been made in terms of legislative matters, including a law
introduced in 1996 aimed at curbing family violence, but that much work on this
front remains.
In the
discussion which ensued among the delegation and the presenters, the following
issues arose: lack of state support or programs for handicapped children in El
Salvador; the high rate of malnutrition in the country as a direct cause of
impaired cognitive abilities among the population; and the high drop-out rate
at all levels in the education system.
C. Site Visit to Parroquia de Sierra Morena, Soyapango
On 24
January 2013, the delegation undertook a site visit to Parroquia de Sierra
Morena in Soyapango (a densely populated working-class city neighbouring San
Salvador). Using the Our Lady of Guadalupe parish as a community meeting area,
for the past four years project co-ordinators at the site have received funding
from the Canadian federal government through the Canada Fund for Local
Initiatives (CFLI) as a volunteer-run violence prevention project. The project
offers programs to both local women, most of whom are low-income single parents
(their spouse having either left them or migrated abroad), and youth at risk
(aged eight to 18). It was noted that the former project has become fully
self-sustaining as a business, and it provides women with a productive skill.
The training
programs offered to women includes cosmetology (at present, four women
participants); bakery and confectionery training (at present six women
participants); silk screening, graphic design and sewing (at present, three
women participants); and production of “api-products” (or products using honey)
(at present, four women participants). The equipment involved in these programs
was purchased with Canadian federal funds. It was further noted that these
women receive English language training while participating in these programs,
and that they also teach the skills that they learn to their children.
The program
for youth at risk involves teaching local children (who reside within five to
ten minutes of the parish) a sport during non-school hours. The purpose of the
program is to offer youth in a poor neighbourhood sport as an option to counter
the potential allure of involvement in gangs and crime. At the time of the
visit, 63 local children participated in learning ping pong. It was noted that
ping pong was chosen as a sport, as opposed to, for example, football, because
the latter is linked to gangs, as gang members often hang around during
football matches.
D. Meeting with NGO
In the
evening of 24 January 2013, the delegation met with an NGO working on security
and justice systems.
The
delegation was provided with a briefing concerning the organization’ background
and purpose, along with information concerning the justice systems, generally,
in Central America. The organization began work in Central America in 1999,
applying the skills it had learned in the context of the Canadian justice
system. In Guatemala, the justice system faced a number of substantial
challenges. The justice system in place prior to the Peace Accords of 1996 was
viewed to have operated principally as a tool of repression. Following the
Peace Accords, Guatemala created a complex justice system, difficult to
administer, as none of the institutions trusted one another. In addition, the
country experienced approximately 35 times the amount of crime as Canada, with
fewer resources at its disposal. The result was a dysfunctional justice system.
It was noted that, until very recently, the conviction rate for murders in Guatemala
was approximately 2% in cases where the accused was caught committing the act.
In cases where investigation was required, however, the conviction rate was
more or less 0%. These numbers have improved but many challenges remain.
The
organization’s role in Central America has been to train about 5,000 to 6,000
individuals involved in the justice system. Phase one of their program involves
teaching skills such as evidence collection and crime scene examination.
Participants stated that good evidence is highly important in prosecuting
cases, as witnesses need to feel confident that a conviction is likely in order
for them to risk testifying. The organization has undertaken a phase two of
training, supported by CIDA funding of $5 million over four years. Phase two
involves major case management and training of judges. The organization was
looking to expand its operations to include training of special units (e.g.
wiretap training), forensic video, and surveillance monitoring. CIDA funding
was subject to renewal and the organization hoped that it would be renewed so
that they may continue this important work.
Participants
also noted that many challenges remain in the region, including: criminality in
prisons; lynchings; no plea bargaining; and constant mistrials. Generally, he
noted that the lack of security in Central America is bad for business and
creates a climate of instability that deters investment.
E. Meeting with private sector organizations
In the
morning of 25 January 2013, the delegation met with members of El Salvador
private sector organisations, including the El Salvador–Canada Chamber of
Commerce for a working breakfast at the Sheraton Presidente Hotel in San
Salvador, El Salvador. In attendance at this meeting were Ambassador Giroux and
members of the Canadian Chamber of Commerce as well as representatives of the
National Association of Private Enterprises (ANEP); Agropecuarian and
Agro-industry Chamber of El Salvador (CAMAGRO); Salvadorian Association of
Industry (ASI); Salvadorian Chamber of Construction (CASALCO); President,
Textile and Free Zones Chamber (CAMTEX, National Development Association
(FUNDE); Sugar Association of El Salvador; and Cleaner Production Centre.
The business
climate arose as a topic of discussion. It was noted that the main challenges
presently facing the economy are political or ideological problems inherited
from past decades. Participants indicated that when the war in the streets of
El Salvador ended in 1992, it moved into, and carried on, in the political
arena. In this respect, it was felt that the country’s politicians are placing
partisan interests ahead of greater national interests. The weakness of
country’s democratic institutions was of concern because it was noted that a
strong link exists between democracy and growth. Comments were also made
concerning the slow growth of the economy over the past half-decade;
insufficient investment; and high rates of crime and violence, which have
caused instability and uncertainty. In respect of the crime rate in the
country, concerns were also expressed that organized crime has penetrated into,
and is influencing, the political sphere.
A potential
free trade agreement between Canada and El Salvador was discussed, with members
of the Chamber of Commerce indicating that such an agreement would create more
jobs in the country and increase much-needed investment. Some exhibited
frustration with the present administration as it has pledged to promote trade.
It was indicated that El Salvador desires to be the regional business hub, akin
to the role presently occupied by Costa Rica.
Concerns
were raised by a number of members of the Chamber of Commerce about the
Trans-Pacific Partnership in terms of demands from certain countries for
flexible rules of origin, and lax environmental and labour rules. It was noted
that allowing these demands to pass would cause great harm to the El
Salvadorian textile industry.
In terms of
other matters, members of the Chamber of Commerce noted the difficulty in
getting a visa and asked that this process be streamlined. Others indicated
that it would be helpful for the country to receive assistance with institution
building. Comments were made that it would be desirable to increase the university-level
exchanges between the two countries. Generally, members of the Chamber
indicated that they remained positive about the state of the country’s economy,
and noted that El Salvadorians are hardworking industrious people who take
pride in making good products.
To conclude,
Ambassador Giroux and Mr. Dreeshen thanked the members for their views and
concerns, and noted that the delegation would return to Canada with a more
balanced view to share with their parliamentary colleagues.
F. Site Visit to Ciudad Mujeres and San Juan Opico
On 25
January 2013, the delegation undertook a site visit to the Ciudad Mujer, in
Santa Ana. There, they were met by Dr. Vanda Pignato, First Lady of El Salvador
and Secretary of Social Inclusion and Citizenship. The Ciudad Mujer is a centre
which offers a comprehensive array of health, education, and wellness services
in a single location to women from poor economic backgrounds who have suffered
from gender-based violence. It has been estimated by the Inter-American Development
Bank that in El Salvador, about half of all women fall victim to violence,
physical or psychological, while only about one-third of those who suffer this
abuse seek help. Called the Ciudad Mujer, meaning “City of Women,” male
visitors are generally not permitted on site. At present, there are four such
centres in El Salvador, with the goal being to open two additional locations.
Each centre is located in high need areas, and offers comprehensive health
services (with an emphasis on sexual and reproductive health); training and
development of economic skills for women; group education; access to police and
justice services; childcare services; and community outreach. These centres
offered services to women and girls who live in municipalities that would not
otherwise be able to adequately respond to the challenges involving violence
against women and girls.
The Ciudad
Mujer project receives Canadian federal funding through the Department of
Foreign Affairs and International Trade, as part of a broader project in El
Salvador and Guatemala to promote the prevention of violence against women.
This overall project received $1.2 million in funding from 31 May 2012 to 31
May 2013, and benefitted approximately 1,800 women directly.
In the
afternoon of 25 January 2013, the delegation visited several sites in the
municipality of San Juan Opico. They were shown two separate women’s training
community centres, aided by Canadian federal funding, where workshops are held
to empower and educate local women. The delegation also visited the Office of
Complaints in the municipality’s police station, used primarily by women who
have been involved in violent situations. With Canadian federal funding, the
office has been completely renovated and refurnished (paint, aromatherapy, air
conditioning, addition of a child play area). These were important upgrades
meant to lend a sense of comfort to women facing extremely difficult
situations. It is in the Office of Complaints that police receive one-on-one
reports and listened to victims of violent gender-based crimes. It was noted
that in 2011, there were 16 women murdered in San Juan Opico, while in 2012,
there were none. It was further noted that Canadian federal funding has been
applied to the promotion of gender equality in training police personnel.
Respectfully
submitted,
Respectfully submitted,
Mr. Earl Dreeshen, M.P.
Head of Delegation
Canadian Section of ParlAmericas