First Session, Forty-second Parliament, 64-65 Elizabeth II, 2015-2016

SENATE OF CANADA

BILL S-231 An Act to amend the Canada Evidence Act and the Criminal Code (protection of journalistic sources)

FIRST READING, November 22, 2016

This enactment amends the Canada Evidence Act to protect the confidentiality of journalistic sources. It allows journalists to not disclose information or a document that identifies or is likely to identify a journalistic source unless the information or document cannot be obtained by any other reasonable means and the public interest in the administration of justice outweighs the public interest in preserving the confidentiality of the journalistic source.

The enactment also amends the Criminal Code so that only a judge of a superior court of criminal jurisdiction or a judge within the meaning of section 552 of that Act may issue a search warrant relating to a journalist. It also provides that a search warrant can be issued only if the judge is satisfied that there is no other way by which the desired information can reasonably be obtained and that the public interest in the investigation and prosecution of a criminal offence outweighs the journalist’s right to privacy in the collection and dissemination of information. The judge must also be satisfied that these same conditions apply before an officer can examine, reproduce or make copies of a document obtained under a search warrant relating to a journalist.

1st Session, 42nd Parliament, 64-65 Elizabeth II, 2015-2016

SENATE OF CANADA

BILL S-231

An Act to amend the Canada Evidence Act and the Criminal Code (protection of journalistic sources)

Her Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate and House of Commons of Canada, enacts as follows:

Start of inserted block

Journalistic Sources

End of inserted block

Definitions

Start of inserted block

39.‍1  (1) The following definitions apply in this section.

document has the same meaning as in section 487.‍011 of the Criminal Code. (document)

journalist means a person who contributes directly, either regularly or occasionally, to the collection, writing or production of information for dissemination by the media, or anyone who assists such a person. (journaliste)

journalistic source means a source that confidentially transmits information to a journalist on the journalist’s undertaking not to divulge the identity of the source, whose anonymity is essential to the relationship between the journalist and the source. (source journalistique)

End of inserted block

Application

Start of inserted block

(2) This section applies despite any other provision of this Act or any other Act of Parliament.

End of inserted block

Objection

Start of inserted block

(3) Subject to subsection (7), a journalist may object to the disclosure of information or a document before a court, person or body with the authority to compel the disclosure of information on the grounds that the information or document identifies or is likely to identify a journalistic source.

End of inserted block

Power of court, person or body

Start of inserted block

(4) The court, person or body may raise the application of subsection (3) on their own initiative.

End of inserted block

Objection of court, person or body

Start of inserted block

(5) When an objection or the application of subsection (3) is raised, the court, person or body shall ensure that the information or document is not disclosed other than in accordance with this section.

End of inserted block

Observations

Start of inserted block

(6) Before determining the question, the court, person or body must give the parties and interested persons a reasonable opportunity to present observations.

End of inserted block

Authorization

Start of inserted block

(7) The court, person or body may authorize the disclosure of information or a document only if the court considers that

• (a) the information or document cannot be produced in evidence by any other reasonable means; and

• (b) the public interest in the administration of justice outweighs the public interest in preserving the confidentiality of the journalistic source, having regard to

  • (i) the essential role of the information or document in the proceeding,

  • (ii) freedom of the press, and

  • (iii) the impact of disclosure on the journalistic source and the journalist.

    End of inserted block

Burden of proof

Start of inserted block

(8) A person who requests the disclosure has the burden of proving that the conditions set out in subsection (7) are fulfilled.

End of inserted block

Appeal

Start of inserted block

(9) An appeal lies from a determination under subsection (7)

• (a) to the Federal Court of Appeal from a determination of the Federal Court;

• (b) to the court of appeal of a province from a determination of a superior court of the province;

• (c) to the Federal Court from a determination of a court, person or body vested with power to compel production by or under an Act of Parliament if the court, person or body is not established under a law of a province; or

• (d) to the trial division or trial court of the superior court of the province within which the court, person or body exercises its jurisdiction, in any other case.

  End of inserted block

Limitation period for appeal

Start of inserted block

(10) An appeal under subsection (9) shall be brought within 10 days after the date of the determination appealed from or within any further time that the court having jurisdiction to hear the appeal considers appropriate in the circumstances.

End of inserted block

Hearing in summary way

Start of inserted block

(11) An appeal under subsection (9) shall be heard and determined without delay and in a summary way.

End of inserted block

Definitions

Start of inserted block

488.‍01  (1) The following definitions apply in this section and in section 488.‍02.

data has the same meaning as in section 487.‍011. (données)

document has the same meaning as in section 487.‍011. (document)

journalist has the same meaning as in subsection 39.‍1(1) of the Canada Evidence Act. (journaliste)

journalistic source has the same meaning as in subsection 39.‍1(1) of the Canada Evidence Act. (source journalistique)

officer means a peace officer or public officer. (fonctionnaire)

End of inserted block

Warrant, authorization and order

Start of inserted block

(2) Despite any other provision of this Act or any other Act of Parliament, a search warrant under this Act, notably under section 487, 487.‍1, 492.‍1 or 492.‍2, or any other Act of Parliament, an authorization under section 184.‍2, 184.‍3, 186 or 188, or an order under any of sections 487.‍014 to 487.‍017 relating to a journalist or an object, document or data relating to or in the possession of a journalist may be issued only by a judge of a superior court of criminal jurisdiction or by a judge within the meaning of section 552.

End of inserted block

Warrant, authorization and order

Start of inserted block

(3) A judge may issue a warrant, authorization or order under subsection (2) only if, in addition to the conditions required for the issue of the warrant, authorization or order, he or she is satisfied that

• (a) there is no other way by which the information can reasonably be obtained; and

• (b) the public interest in the investigation and prosecution of a criminal offence outweighs the journalist’s right to privacy in gathering and disseminating information.

  End of inserted block

Conditions

Start of inserted block

(4) The warrant, authorization or order may contain any conditions that the judge considers appropriate to protect the confidentiality of journalistic sources and to limit the disruption of journalistic activities.

End of inserted block

Powers

Start of inserted block

(5) The judge who rules on the application for the warrant, authorization or order has the same powers, with the necessary adaptations, as the authority who may issue the warrant, authorization or order.

End of inserted block

Documents

Start of inserted block

488.‍02 (1) Any document obtained pursuant to a warrant, authorization or order issued under subsection 488.‍01(3) is to be placed in a packet and sealed by the court that issued the warrant, authorization or order and is to be kept in the custody of the court in a place to which the public has no access or in such other place as the judge may authorize and is not to be dealt with except in accordance with this section.

End of inserted block

Notice

Start of inserted block

(2) No officer is to examine or reproduce, in whole or in part, a document referred to in subsection (1) or make copies of it without giving the journalist and relevant media outlet notice of his or her intention to examine or reproduce the document or make copies of it.

End of inserted block

Application

Start of inserted block

(3) The journalist or relevant media outlet may, within 10 days of receiving the notice referred to in subsection (2), apply to a judge of the court that issued the warrant, authorization or order to issue an order that the document is not to be disclosed to an officer on the grounds that the document identifies or is likely to identity a journalistic source.

End of inserted block

Disclosure: prohibition

Start of inserted block

(4) A document that is subject to an application under subsection (3) is to be disclosed to an officer only following a disclosure order in accordance with paragraph (7)‍(b).

End of inserted block

Disclosure order

Start of inserted block

(5) The judge may order the disclosure of a document only if he or she is satisfied that

• (a) there is no other way by which the information can reasonably be obtained; and

• (b) the public interest in the investigation and prosecution of a criminal offence outweighs the journalist’s right to privacy in gathering and disseminating information.

  End of inserted block

Examination

Start of inserted block

(6) The judge may, if he or she considers it necessary, examine a document to determine whether it should be disclosed.

End of inserted block

Order

Start of inserted block

(7) The judge must,

• (a) if he or she is of the opinion that the document should not be disclosed, order that it be returned to the journalist or the media outlet, as the case may be; or

• (b) if he or she is of the opinion that the document should be disclosed, order that it be delivered to the officer who gave the notice under subsection (2), subject to such restrictions and conditions as the judge deems appropriate.

488.‍03 Sections 488.‍01 and 488.‍02 apply despite any other provision of this Act or any other Act of Parliament.

End of inserted block

Canada Evidence Act

Clause 2: New.

Criminal Code

Clause 3: New.